
Chicago’s New May Day Tradition
By Megan Chapman, interviews by Cindy Schaarschmidt, May 16, 2007
The numbers are down, but hopes are up. Over 150,000 marched for immigration reform on May 1, 2007 in downtown Chicago, compared with the 400,000 on May 1, 2006.
Standing on the corner of Dearborn and Jackson, at the edge (or at times in midst) of the forward-marching crowd, a friend and I speculated about the numbers. The police count of 150,000 was already being reported online when we had left our offices. We came up with a variety of hypothetical explanations for why the numbers would be more than halved from one year to the next. The leading explanations were:
(1) People don’t have hope. It’s taking too long to negotiate immigration reform legislation in Congress. Apathy sets in again. We’re not going to change anything.
(2) People do have hope. We’ve already won half the battle – there’s a Democratic Congress, the President is on board and making stump speeches again. It’s just a matter of time. No need to skip work.
(3) Reaction motivates more than pro-action. Last year’s House Bill 4437 struck a chord amongst immigrant communities and advocates. And, frankly, most sane, humanitarian-minded folk. While recent Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) raids have been dramatic and threatening, they do not motivate the same fervent reaction as the drastic HR4437 enforcement measures or the media captivating Minute Men.
(4) Sequels don’t play as well as the originals, at least not in activism.
None of these lines of thought are meant to discount the grand numbers that did turn out to march for miles in the sun and rally in Grant Park. There’s nothing little about 150,000 (plus) bodies. Ask anyone who has tried to organize an anti-war march or a Sudan rally … or an anti-immigrant march, for that matter.